Chaos and fast oscillations in the human brain and mental processes

With the application of nonlinear dynamics to the analysis of the human EEG and MEG (magnetoencephalogram) it has become feasible to estimate the number of processes necessary for the production of a time series such as the human EEG or MEG: We developed special mathematical algorithms derived from the theory of deterministic chaos to estimate the dimension of time series which is within certain limits a monotonous function of the number of processes necessary to construct an actual EEG or MEG trace. In more than 40 experiments these algorithms were applied to a vast array of human states such as mental activity, consciousness, pathological states and psychopharmacological influences.

If we assume that each cortical network has its own characteristic temporal dynamics which is apparent in the EEG trace, then the dimension estimates the number of independently active cell assemblies, i.e the cortical complexity, for a given mental, motor or sensory activity. Table 1 gives examples of EEG-complexity, which is a monotonous function of the number of independent cell assemblies of the EEG during different activities. Each cell represents the result of one experiment.


Table 1 Cortical complexity: Summary of findings
States of consciousness
coma (apallic syndrome) decreased compared to wakefulness
anesthesia (with sedatives) reduced compared to wakefulness and dreaming (REM)
sleep markedly reduced during deep (slow wave) sleep compared to wakefulness and dreaming (REM)
menstrual cycle no differences during different phases of the cycle
Development, Aging and Personality
7 years up to 50 years monotonous increase with age intelligence, increased in intelligent persons when no stimulus presented,no difference during stimulus presentation or task performance
musically sophisticated versus untalented subjects markedly reduced during regular rhythmical music in subjects preferring simple ("pop") music
Perception
eyes closed no difference to eyes open imagery, always increased during imagination of objects, sounds or temperature compared to real perception of the same objects
observing double versus simple pendulum increased with double figures music increased with more unpredictable (complex) music
Cognitive processes
focused attention reduced compared to imagery and rest attentiveness
reduced during diffuse-passive stimulus anticipation compared to task preparation concentration
during distraction increased divergent thinking
("creativity") slightly increased compared to convergent thinking
mental rotation during simple rotation higher than during complex rotation
stroop-test reduced compared to rest, no interference effects
Motor process
relaxation exercises no difference to rest
deep breathing (hyperventilation) no difference to rest
tapping local increase over hand areas (C3 and C4) fine motor task (Luria), increased complexity with fine motor compared to tapping task
Emotional processes
positive feelings increased compared to negative feelings during rest condition
love pronouncedly reduced in persons in love compared to persons not in love, no difference during mental activity
pain reduced during thermic pain compared to control condition (only in pain insensitive persons)
Pathology and pharmaca
smoking reduced in smokers after smoking
Clonazepam (antiepileptic) increased compared to placebo
Carbamazepin (antiepileptic) no change compared to placebo
Parkinson½s disease increased during performance and during imagination of complex motor tasks
schizophrenia markedly increased in frontal lobe, reduced parietal lobe
chronic pain increased during imagined pain in pain patients and pain sensitive persons compared to rest condition and healthy persons
tinnitus (noise in the ear) increased compared to healthy persons

The estimate of the number of simultaneously active cell assemblies contains no information about the functional meaning of the activity of a given assembly. Mental activity is represented in Hebbian cell assemblies which oscillate proportional to their anatomical size and connections within the cerebral cortex. These oscillations are frequently called gamma-band or 40Hz oscillations because they can be found only in the high-frequency beta range. From animal experiments it is concluded that synchronous high frequency activity indicates Hebbian strengthening of cell assemblies ("binding") necessary to represent meaning and Gestalt in the nervous system. Each mental act is represented in a topographically different assembly which has in a specific frequency of oscillation. If these oscillations represent the construction of meaning, Gestalt or context in the nervous system, they should appear whenever humans find meaning in a formally meaningless pattern. This was confirmed for the visual modality and for language (see Neurobiology of Language

Birbaumer, N., Flor, H., Lutzenberger, W. & Elbert, T. (1994). Chaos and order in the human brain. In G. Karmos & M. Molnar (Eds): Perspectives of Event Related Potentials Research. EEG Suppl. 44, 448-457, Amsterdam: Elsevier.

Elbert, T., Ray, W.J., Kowalik, Z.J., Skinner, J.E., Graf, K.E. & Birbaumer, N. (1994). Chaos and Physiology: Deterministic Chaos in Excitable Cell Assemblies. Physiological Reviews, 74, 1, 1 - 4787. Lutzenberger,W., Pulvermüller, F., Elbert,T. & Birbaumer, N. (1995). Visual stimulation alters local 40-Hz responses in humans: an EEG study. Neuroscience Letters 183, 1-4.

Schupp, H.T., Lutzenberger, W., Birbaumer, N., Miltner, W. & Braun, C. (1994). Neurophysiological differences between perception and imagery. Cognitive Brain Research 2, 77-86.


Home-Page
Hubert Preißl
Maintainer: hubert.preissl@uni-tuebingen.de(hubert.preissl@uni-tuebingen.de)